Whiteout Survival State ReviewAdd Review

Whiteout Survival - State #2649 Reviews

Group 15

Summary

The state has a mixed reputation, with strong unity and leadership praised, but toxicity, drama, and manipulation heavily criticized.

Overall Rating

3.2

Toxicity Level

2.9

Reviews

44 reviews. 6 irrelevant reviews hidden and not counted towards the state's rating.

Rating:

8/18/2025

I’ve been in 2649 since the beginning and it was my first time playing the game. The state is fun, no toxic players and we all work together for the best interests of the state goals

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/18/2025

Toxic PlayersState Politics

I don't agree with people giving 5 stars and nothing else, it seems like they are quite blind and don't see everything. I'm a woman and I get ugly messages from men. It was worse months ago but it didn't stop. I guess the women commenting are hiding their gender. Any way. This state is Okey, but it's more dead than toxic, players quit because of the toxic history and drama. The worst drama players quit, but the worst manipulators are still there, they are everywhere.......

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/18/2025

From what this state was from the beginning to where it is now, its day and night. In its early days there was lots of toxicity with power plays self broken Nap rules at points it was unbearable to see and read and then comes Dave arrogant at first all he wanted to do is burn things as progressed Dave surpassed us all in all categories just blindsiding us with all this power but he didn’t use his might to burn thing as he claimed he would but he became a uniter and a true leader of our state needed, he forged treaties with other leaders for the peace of the state he made us believe that unity outweighs any power together we can dominate and ever since the first SVS there’s been no looking and there’s order in our state, yes we might not be perfect we still have some cracks to fill and bumps to flatten, but over all this is a great state and I wouldn’t change it for no other.

Verified
Rating:
Toxicity:

8/18/2025

Toxic PlayersState Politics

Reading these other reviews really doesnt resonate of my own experience in this state. Im female and have seen none of the behaviour mentioned! Only one incident but that was not a state issue! Ive been in several alliances, been R4 and R5 and I can honestly say I was given so much guidance and help from the more experienced players. I find the NAP and any rules well explained, help is given to every player that wishes to access it. I find most other members easy to get along with and pretty chilled out. There will always be those that you dont get along with or like as much but thats life! Cant be everyones cup of tea! The accusations about Dave also dont match up to my opinion. Yes, he is no BS and pretty straight up, I appreciate that! But he also leads fairly, includes players that arent whales or higher levels. I have characters in other states and I find myself focusing on this state as I really enjoy how everyone comes together whether as an alliance in events or as a whole state for svs. Definitely somewhere you can increase your knowledge, have fun and make friends, regardless of whether you're a whale, dolphin, p2p or f2p.

Verified
Rating:
Toxicity:

8/18/2025

Toxic Players

As a female player and first time player of this type of game. I love this state. I have had great experiences and made awesome friends. There will always be a s****y person but I don't involve myself and the leadership has done a good job taking care of them fairly. I have seen leadership burn their own state down in anger after losing SvS. And realized how truly lucky I am in this state! There seems to be an alliance for everyone and every type of player here. Honestly I totally recommend this state as Home!

Verified
Rating:
Toxicity:

8/18/2025

Toxic PlayersState Politics

Ok I guess I need to step in as well. This state.. Some comments are true and some are pure lies. There is specifically one comment who had been made by mental illness. Guardian is not worth the lies in the comments below. He's one of the guys who made the foundation for the state best possible. It's not only him, but this is about him since the comment was made below full of not correct info. I think we all know who it is and we don't need to out him here as well, but he's mentioned as an "opponent" to Guardian, and he doesn't have problems with anyone else and are well respected in the state and talks good about people. The thing is: Guardian can be hard sometimes but he is not stupid at all. I've seen conversations with him and the other part when he totally gets demolished in arguments by Guardian and then the other part starts talking about non relevant things or starting personal attacks. I've been a long member of the same alliance and I've been about to leave several times because of one single leader who always giving wrong info, or making new rules without consulting others. I remember a very specific incident when the R4 didn't get into our biggest whales bear rally, and then in the middle of the rally made new rules about how many troops you can join, even if more experienced player told It's not going to work, the "other" part ignored it and it became a big issue. As well as I understand he also extremely upset about being worth of row 1 instead of a rally leader because he was R4. This started a huge conflict in the alliance. Anyone with experience in this game know it takes one man to ruin a party. But don't spread lies about Guardian, he was a really intelligent and good leader, a part who made this state a better place and not a complete warzone. And for the ones wondering, this state is ok. I guess all states has there issues, this is not the worst available, it's not the best available. #FreeGuardian

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

State Politics

I couldn't in good conscience give it a 0 on the toxicity scale but it's for the most part a peaceful state. SavageDave (mega whale) has been the leader here since the first svs.. There have been a few different presidents but Dave is the leader. Top 4 alliances band together for svs exchanging players in order to achieve the best outcome and they work together outside of SVS to help eachother grow. This state has a very team oriented mentality. Top 4 alliances. ONE - very strategic no BS and in it to win it ROC - Strategic friendly, good people HDN - Laid back and fun and friendly, unfortunately they have a barley active r5 who doesn't know what he's doing... which is unfortunate because they have a few great players who would do a much better job. SEA - Korean alliance active and strong they have a few whales but no sense of humor and a lot gets lost in translation. I think anyone who joins 2649 could find an alliance that suits them and would have a happy gaming experience.

Rating:

8/17/2025

A very apparent and clearly co ordinated smear campaign . Coincidently aligned with Group 15 State Transfer event. The state is democratic true to approach .It's apparent many who see them selves on the way out they want to drag and burn everything through fire and mud . Contrary to belief yes Dave a " whale or mega whale" what ever you want to label him is a fair leader , not vulgar decent and respectfull regardless of his power level . No threats or rogue action of burning down the state . Contrary to great praise given to the following Guardian- Profession discord and disruption master . He is truly the meaning of all for one , one for all . If your not part of his agenda your against him and will endeavour to make your game play experience painful as possible . Not limited to but a honorable mention , turning world chat into a episode of Jerry Springer . Prejudising a specific ethnic alliance , indoctrinating and influencing nap policy to exclude specific key players due to above ethnic prejudices . He will system.atically try to create cult idolise of himself . IF HE TRANSFERS , LORD HELP YOUR STATE. 2649 has always respected women , it has seen and has key state influential female alliance members at r4 and above current and historic . There a reason for why 2649 is a leading state into its first state transfer . It's because there is strength in unity not through dictator ship . No amount kf fear will make people win 4/4 svs prep and 3/4 battle wins . Use logic and common sense . The smear campaign is there to keep you away . Don't believe the fake news .

Verified
Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic Players

I thought long and hard on how to do this. I've been with the state since the beginning. Just the basics. This state is led by a NAP 4 and 3 academies. I'll go through each one and give a fair and honest review from lowest ranked to highest. At the bottom of the list we have USA. USA is ran by Stella. She is a inexperienced player and doesn't have a clue what is going on most of the time. A couple of her players often go off on a wild tangent and will attack other players while gathering. Her alliance is made up of the most inexperienced players of the state. Second lowest of the academies we have PLN. PLN is ran by Reskinator at R5. They do have a handful of dolphins that keep the alliance alive. But when opportunities to merge and become stronger came about Reskinator was the fall of those attempts each time. They do mostly keep to themselves. The last of the academies is TRK. TRK is ran by Khan at R5. TRK was once a powerhouse of the state rivaling in the top 3. They were strong and powerful bringing unity to the turks and even having non turks in the alliance. What they are now is just a shell of what they once were. Through manipulation and scare tactics Khan and his R4s brought the alliance down. Without Dayi or Ahmed this alliance would fall. At the bottom of NAP 4 we have HND. HND is led by Legend. HND was once powerful when it was GOD and led by Odin. Odin ran GOD through decent tactics but manipulation. A bunch of drama severed the alliance causing him and the experienced players to flee the alliance leaving Legend at R5. HND is a mostly peaceful alliance that have no idea of what they are doing and cant even run a proper bear trap. If it wasn't for Speedy and Potato this alliance would be a academy. The R4s are just placed there without even knowing how to do their jobs and don't correct their members when they do the same thing wrong over and over again. In 3rd of NAP we have SEA. SEA is ran by Priod and is a decent alliance. They have decent players and Priod, Victor, dominate the towers during SVS. They stay pretty quite and keep to themselves. They of course have their own problem children but are quick to correct members that get out of line. In the number 2 position we have ROK. ROK alternate the R5 position between Carat and JuicyJohn. This is a solid alliance with the sometimes occasional mishap between the lower members but is corrected very quickly. Downside is a couple of their R4s that don't know what the h*** they are doing or know what they are talking about. But overall ROK can definitely hold their own. And finally the number 1 alliance of State 2649 is ONE. ONE is ran by the whale of the state Savage Dave. They have a very solid alliance and the R4s get the job done when Dave or Rice isn't online. I will say they rule fairly and equally with th other members of NAP. Yes, there was drama between Guardian and Doom and things could have been handled differently on both sides but that happens with any alliance. Overall 2649 is a good state. Members of the state have gone back and forth figuring out which alliance is best for them. The state along with their leader Savage Dave have proved they are on their way to dominate. There is good cohesion between the NAP and for the most part academies. Agendas are voted upon with the R5s and R4s of the state and rewards are merit based. State 2649 isn't perfect by any means but they are definitely working together to make it the best they can be. Each alliance has their own problem children but for the most part they are dealt with accordingly.

Verified
Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic PlayersToxic AllianceState Politics

Don't get fooled by chatgpt 5 stars. I don't even know where to start. There are so many sick people who play innocent victims, persecute, provoke, and destroy others. They can't live without drama, conflicts, and hatred. If there are no enemies, they create them themselves and then 'fight' against them together. If you don't want to hate, anger, or blackmail others, stay away from these people. If you enjoy bullying others in a group, then this is the perfect place for you. As someone who used to love this state, it honestly hurts to see how it’s crumbling. People can talk all they want about ‘growth’ but the reality is clear: toxicity drove out good players and the so-called ‘best state’ is now a shadow of what it could’ve been. I hope those still there realise they deserve better. Without the mega-whale SavageDave, this state would have been very dead a long time ago. Without SavageDave this state would lose every SvS. He's the reason why they are winning. Guardian was not a whale but he did everything for the future of the state, but he disappeared because he got enough of all the hatred and manipulation in the state. ONE alliance with SavageDave, Guardian and Rice was good once, but fell apart because of R4 Ken aka doomslayer. ROC with mushy and carat is good, they are good people. Then you have the baby elephant and sung, they are just talking nonsense all the time. But most of the alliance is like a baby playground. HDN is ruled by a baby, biggest drama leader ever, it was a mess being in this alliance with such a s*** leader. SEA have a few whales, you never know their intentions and can backstab you at any second. TRK, stay away from them. They are the biggest manipulators gathered in the same alliance. Ruled by the biggest manipulators is Khan himself and they always have a hidden agenda. Then it's a few small alliances who doesn't matter at all, but peaceful. It's also hard to be a woman in this state. Again. Don't get fooled by 5 star chatgpt comments.

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic PlayersToxic AllianceState Politics

A beautiful at first that wants peace around. But, they wanted most of the power and was successful in stealing it making the state one of the worst out there. Blaming an alliance and pointing it out as an alliance that wants to have all the power which is very much a false statement they made in order to grab the opportunity to gain power on their side. Such a toxic manipulating state. Be careful and be aware. They don't like turks.

Rating:

8/17/2025

Honest Review of State 2649 Every place has its own problems — no state is perfect. I’ve tried creating accounts in several states, but so far, State 2649 has been the best experience for me. Here, people can be rivals at one moment and allies the next, yet they always know how to have fun together. When they are united, the teamwork is real. And whenever problems arise, there’s always a way to solve them — and they actually make it happen. So don’t worry about joining State 2649. At least try talking to some of the people here, and you’ll see for yourself why this state is special.

Rating:

8/17/2025

This state is fun first. I’m a casual player with a full time job and there is very little pressure from other players to push spending money to grow fast. The mom in me does worry a little reading here because basic internet safety could prevent some of the scary things mentioned here. But this is my first time hearing about these issues so they might not be about 2649. Read with caution I guess.

Rating:

8/17/2025

Looks like most of this review was written by one haters of the state who broke rules, and couldn't manipulate the mass. Fun states, we do karaoke! LOL tap tap.

Rating:

8/17/2025

State 2649 isn’t perfect ,,like any state we’ve had ups and downs ,, but overall our leadership and whales actually work together toward common goals. We don’t have a ton of whales, but the ones we do have pull their weight and push the entire state forward instead of acting like dictators. Most of our success comes from straight-up hard work, unity, and smart leadership. Just look at our SVS win history ,,, that speaks for itself. If you're looking for a state where effort is recognized, rewards are shared based on merit, and people move as a team, then 2649 is 100% worth transferring to

Rating:

8/17/2025

Like any state, it started off a little wild with the usual drama and wannabe dictators,but lucky for us, our whales actually have common sense and care about the people. They’re generous, protective, and focus on growing the whole server, not just themselves. We run on strict NAP rules and fair play. If you put in work, you get rewarded. It’s competitive, organized, and the whales here actually look out for the little guy.... not eat them.

Rating:

8/17/2025

State of Fair is honestly one of the chillest Whiteout Survival servers I’ve been in. People actually earn their rewards here — everything is shared based on merit, not politics or butt-kissing. If you grind and contribute, you get recognized. Alliances work together instead of fighting over scraps, and the community has good vibes overall. It’s competitive without being toxic, and the leadership tries to make things fair for all active players. Highly recommend transferring here if you want rewards that actually reflect your effort and a server culture that isn’t full of drama.

Verified
Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic Players

Fun state, started out with lots of players working on their second or third accounts so we had a lot of guidance to start out. Most of the time the state is peaceful and playful. We have had a few egotistical players that aren’t even whales start drama that everyone gets involved in because it’s all over world chat. No one gets the full story because the guys have been master manipulators. Once again not the whale players just guys that talk too much in my opinion.

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic PlayersToxic AllianceState Politics

Don't let the svs wins fool you. There are some nice players but majority of leaders are manipulators. They make it sound so good and they backstabbing you

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic Players

This state will always be toxic as long as the same harem fantasy loving men live here. Women are treated as playthings and nothing more and it is DISGUSTING. Imagine having a girlfriend or wife at home and then parading around nudes you recieved like trophies. These whales are fully delusional threatening people to post positive reviews, I wasn't going to post at all, but if they want me to write a review it will be an honest one.

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic PlayersToxic AllianceState Politics

You’ll see a lot of the 5* reviews are just them trying to defend themselves. They need to grow up and reflect on how all of us are still upset IN STATE. Majority of these 1* reviews are currently active in the state but they’re trying to use the people that left as a scapegoat and blame it on them rather than taking responsibility. Sad to see honestly. Thanks for the option to leave soon, and they can keep their manipulative show. Stay away.

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic PlayersToxic AllianceState Politics

Not worth the time coming here. Passes are withheld from you even when promises so don’t expect your friends allowed to transfer here after you come. If you’re a whale you’ll be treated like gold, otherwise you’re trash and made fun of.

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic PlayersState Politics

2649 is an illusion. The illusion of harmony. Here, people do not know what harmony is and will never find it. They write about it and the next day send battle reports. This state is on the brink of collapse. As long as you lie about other states, you will drown in lies.

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic PlayersToxic AllianceState Politics

This used to be a good state. You can rank good for events even if you are F2P. But every alliance has their own agenda in the background while appearing like the are working together for the good of the state. Individuals appear very friendly in world chat but back bite and say derogatory statements about other players. LOTS OF PROBLEMS INVOLVING SVS. Most of the problems are hidden among the R4 & R5 of each alliance and the remaining players just receive the news that their R4 & R5 give out. Because of this, the lies and rumors are circulating and the truth has been twisted. I would DEFINITELY NOT RECOMMEND this state. I'm just accummulating my transfer passes and then I will go out of this rut of a state!

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic PlayersToxic AllianceState Politics

The state exhibits a culture marked by selfishness. The leadership is egocentric and does not prioritize collective growth. There is a resistance to accepting stronger players, creating a stagnant and hostile environment. Better to avoid it to not die of boredom. It's sad.

Rating:

8/17/2025

Some of the nicest people I have met have been in this state. We work as a group for svs prep and castle battle.

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic PlayersToxic AllianceState Politics

Extreme state politics, region based hatred, racism is heavily observed, control of power to one alliance, felt like Trump is running the state 😂 There is one boss, rest with slave mentality, no opportunity for growth, all medieval methods of playing, don't want to try new things, can't tolerate stronger players in another alliance, don't learn from other's wisdom, state has been broken many times and it will continue to break too, they do not have any vision or strategy for any state event. They don't allow friendly rallies at SFC battle, don't try new formations and no learning from reports, even don't even know how to identify buffs, do not agree with approach from playing from one state alliance, only agree to approach of asking people joining top alliance in case they need them even when they just have 10 spots, otherwise no need for that as well, people can rot in their alliances. They prefer keeping their own inactives in their alliance rather than playing from a shell alliance with 100 active players at the time of SvS or FDT. Except top alliance, rest alliances are in really poor condition, even basic understanding of game is lacking, they are just happy to get free facilities and forts as they have weak mindset and no aspiration to grow. one alliance is crazy, leader do solo on fortress everytime stating it will get looted by some random player from dead alliance. Also the leader thinks that everyone should get a chance to stay inside fort to get some rewards post first capture 😂 doesn't know anything about how rewards are generated. State rules says they can't even punish random occasional player from some dead alliance for taking fortress from main alliance causing loss of first capture rewards to 15 people of serious alliance, they say let that one random a** player grow who don't even know how to play 😂.

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic PlayersToxic AllianceState Politics

This state struggles with strict rules, inactive alliances, bullying by stronger players, and a declining player base. Avoid moving here.

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic PlayersToxic AllianceState Politics

This place is the death to all good things, a direct consequence of its toxic leadership. Do not be fooled by the fake five-star reviews, which are merely propaganda designed to hide the truth. The cities are literally crumbling under their misguidance. The true nature of this place is constant backstabbing and fires. Save yourself the heartbreak and the despair; go anywhere else

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

State PoliticsToxic AllianceToxic Players

Honestly, it's a bunch of chronically online adults with some kids sprinkled in. There are a few problem people who just keep coming back and causing drama like the weird kid in high school that had a crush on on the other weird kid that just wouldn't catch the hint that hung around your group of friends, but your all too nice to say anything so you play nice together everyday even though they are constantly stealing and lying and saying you did it..but other than that everything is pretty chill. Everyone has their Friend group and I think if we had more transfers and active chats and bonded more things would be less lord of flies because of the weird couple of weird kids and their vendetta on the computer nerds because, they are winning.

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

State PoliticsToxic PlayersToxic AllianceBroken NAPs

Ah, my birthplace… I’ll always remember the feeling of logging in and realising my home was no longer mine. Conquered by manipulators, reshaped without a thought for those who built it. You made it clear..your loyalty is to greed, not to your own people. So I left, and I’m thriving where unity still means something. Goodbye forever 2649

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic PlayersToxic AllianceState PoliticsBroken NAPs

Mixed feelings prevail, with strong negative sentiments towards certain aspects, while others remain unaddressed or neutral in feedback....

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic AllianceToxic PlayersState Politics

This state started out well, but after repeated miscommunication and "miscommunication" events have taken a dive, and world chat becomes toxic or disgusting quickly. There are only ONE or two good alliances left.

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic PlayersToxic AllianceState PoliticsBroken NAPs

More peaceful than it used to be, but still some bully players… Whales only attack F2P, weaker alliances. VVV rules the state but they became more stable after they split with KOR, which is now an extension of VVV with all the bullies. FWL looks after rewards, selfish profit and bow in front of Whales but bully others if they stand in front of them, only using their whales to weak F2P…

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic PlayersToxic AllianceState Politics

The state enjoyed peaceful cooperation and success initially, but toxic players now dominate, causing chaos, bullying, and mass exits.

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic PlayersToxic AllianceState Politics

Didn't think I was ever going to have to post this but I want to warn others about the state I once argued in favor of. Day1 R4, current R5, past president so I know all the history. The good and the bad. Original account was in the low triple digits so this ain't my first rodeo. Early state drama was put to rest when the last of the toxic players left. We had a good run of peaceful cooperative play among all alliances. We won most of our SvS. Dozens of players quit an already quiet state. Tons more transferred out. I stayed back to wait for my friends to accumulate passes and try to keep it calm for the sake of the remaining players. I'm leaving, along with all my active alliance members and the other alliances are doing the same. Several alliances have disbanded. So once we are all gone in 2 weeks there might be 2 alliances left. Maybe. I post this to warn others of what they are walking into. This isn't a farmer complaining about a competitive server. We all dropped power because we want to join a leading state for the competition. This isn't a f2p crying about spenders, I'm a moderate spender. This is about a tyrant running the state and wanting everything for themselves. They said we have to let the "whale" win every event. They said their top 5 is to visit every alliance to receive fort rewards. They put in a spin doctor as their R5 to make it look like they are kind. So don't be fooled. Do yourself a favor and skip 2649 when you are searching for a new server.

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic PlayersState PoliticsToxic Alliance

Toxic Ken in ONE alliance. Sentiment is negative, highlighting dysfunctional alliances, dictatorship, manipulation, and severe consequences for leaving, with no positive aspects mentioned.

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic PlayersToxic AllianceState Politics

What was thought to be an alliance that would help grow and rebuild, turned out to be a group of people who TRULY only look and strive to destroy, bully, and belittle. In World Chat, they say obscenities to women, they call people racial slurs (yes, THAT word), they megaphone threats to the state and alliances about burning them if you don't do what they want. They burn banners, HQ's and cities with no regard to established state rules that have kept the peace before they arrived. They threaten to demolish you if you don't partipate in Svs. They pride themselves on being "State Killers" apparently as well. Please, keep these tyrants OUT of your state! Make sure you grab their ID numbers from the other reviews about them in here and put them on ur blacklist! Keep your state safe!

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

State PoliticsToxic AllianceToxic PlayersBroken NAPs

This state faces chaos with internal conflicts, failed sales, discrimination concerns, and messy SVS events, eroding community decency

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

State PoliticsToxic AllianceToxic Players

A once peaceful and thriving state. Unfortunately, state transfer brought in terrible people. This one alliance in particular formed a dictatorship which caused many active players to leave the following few transfers. They claim to want peace yet burn cities for no reason. Avoid this now dead state.

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic AllianceState PoliticsBroken NAPs

The state faces intense criticism for toxic leadership, power abuse, and drama, though some praise its friendly, SVS-focused community.

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

State PoliticsToxic PlayersBroken NAPsToxic Alliance

This state faces criticism for untrustworthy alliances and poor management, creating a negative, declining environment for players.

Rating:
Toxicity:

8/17/2025

Toxic AllianceState PoliticsToxic Players

This state is extremely toxic. I have another account in a different state and it's honestly night and day difference. 2649 have lots of dictators, they burn out of spite and vindictiveness, and they certainly don't work together.

Rating:

8/17/2025

A** leadership, manipulative leaders